Summer Thornton is no stranger to updating historic homes for modern-day living: Over the course of her career, she’s worked her magic on landmarked Art Deco apartments, a former lakeside inn, and her own Chicago Victorian. So when a couple asked Thornton to update a sprawling 1874 farmhouse a stone’s throw from the water in Traverse City, Michigan, she was more than prepared to find the right balance of old-time charm with of-the-moment convenience.
“Our goal was to protect and embrace the historical integrity and charm of the home and neighborhood, but make it function well for a family with three young boys,” says Thornton, who was joined on the three-year project by her firm’s designer Whitney Mersman. “They are a fun, young family, and we wanted to inject that energy in the design, too!”
To accomplish that, her team embraced an ebulliently eclectic medley of color, pattern, and materials. The theme is immediately evident upon entering the foyer, with its 18th-century inspired Pierre Frey striped wallpaper, sleek alabaster pendant lights, and a 19th-century antique wood console, above which hangs an electric Andy Warhol print. “We wanted you to walk in and know this house was going to be fun-loving and witty,” Thornton explains.
The dining room is similarly character driven. “We took the formality out and instead filled it with warmth and layers,” says Thornton. The original wood-burning fireplace and adjacent firewood storage nook were left intact, with the surrounding brick receiving a coat of white paint, while the room’s original wood ceiling beams were recreated. Another patterned wallpaper, a linear floral based on an 18th-century “indienne” motif that could be a cousin of the foyer’s, adds movement, while a striped Anatolian kilim rug makes a graphic statement.
When it came to the kitchen, Thornton’s team rethought the entire floorplan. “Originally, the space was laid out in many small, separate areas. We redesigned the layout and opened it up, but still kept the farmhouse charm,” says the designer. Newly installed gray-and-white honed limestone floors appear as if they could date back to the 19th century, as does the well-worn antique French farm table. The space is by no means a period piece, though: Rich plum cabinets (in Farrow & Ball’s Brinjal) with gleaming brass hardware bring the glamour, while Josef Hoffmann’s bentwood-and-cane counter stools add a modern note.
During the renovation, the homeowners also added two new buildings—a two-bedroom carriage house and a small pool house—to the property. “We wanted them to fit seamlessly into the historical architecture of the main house,” Thornton explains. While the interiors of the pool house were “a bit of an intentional departure” (think walls and ceilings lined in pale knotty pine and sleek marble countertops), details like the green-and-white checkerboard marble floors offer subtle nods to the main house. “It’s a sophisticated party pad!” enthuses Thornton.